Don't Miss

Ep 183 : The Phantom Editor Responds To Ahmed Best – with Mike J Nichols

By on August 27, 2018


In the early 2000’s The Phantom Edit was the most hyped VHS tape in Hollywood.

The purpose of the edit, according to creator Mike J. Nichols, was to make a much stronger version of The Phantom Menace based on the previous execution and philosophies of film storytelling and editing of George Lucas.

Whilst to the casual Star Wars viewer the difference to the film might be unnoticeable, many in the media misleadingly sensationalized the underground tape to have totally edited out Jar Jar Binks.

Recently Ahmed Best on his exceptional field notes YouTube series spoke about the hurt the edit caused him.

The Phantom Edit’s creator Mike J. Nichols returns to the podcast to discuss Ahmed’s recent comments on the landmark fan edit and look at fan discourse and criticism then and now.

Watch Ahmed Best’s Field Notes
Field Notes Ep 3

Listen to the original Phantom Editor interview!
Ep 016 : The Phantom Editor – The re-editor of Star Wars Episode 1 The Phantom Menace

Watch Star Wars: Episode I.II – The Phantom Edit
DVD Commentary by Mike J. Nichols

For podcast advertising enquires contact Claire on

Part of The Planet Broadcasting Podcast Network and The Making Star Wars Podcast Network.

For more like minded pop culture podcasts
For more like minded Star Wars podcasts
Get Your Snoke Theory Sucks & other Steele Wars merch at
For bonus content and to help support the podcast please check out

Producer – Rashad Qasem
Chat Overloard – Emily Lind
Show notes – Dom Legaspi
Theme music – Paul Dempsey